Skip to main content

Tiny Cottage on Columbia Avenue

I’ve been on a personal quest to try to find out if and where Addie Perryman lived on her land.  Several sources say that she raised her family on her allotment land, but US Census Records place her in rented homes near, but not on her land. 

One very old tiny cottage, located at 1302 S. Columbia Avenue, has been rumored to be “the original farm house” for the entire area so I wanted to investigate if this could have been Addie's home. I was able to contact the owner who shared some information and permitted me to check out the property abstract.  I’ll jump to the punch line.  Addie Perryman never lived there.  But!  Some interesting people with important history owned the property in years gone by.

                                                                               *****

First some relevant facts and short timeline about the property.

The property of 1302 and 1308 S. Columbia Avenue has a legal description of Lots One and Two, Hurst’s Re-subdivision of Block 5, Fair Acres Addition to the City of Tulsa, Tulsa County. 

As with all of the property in the boundary on the west side of RNA (Lewis Avenue to Delaware Ave and 11th and 15 Streets) the land was allotted to a Native American Creek woman named Addie Perryman about 1903. Read about Addie here:  

In March of 1920, L.A. Hurst and Lutie Hurst re-subdivided part of a larger addition called Fair Acres.  The 1920 Census lists Mr. Hurst’s profession as a “realtor” and he and Lutie lived with their two daughters at 313 West Chicago, Tulsa, Oklahoma.  (Probably an old street name- West Chicago Street no longer exists.) 

In September 1920, Lot 1, Block 1 of the Hurst Addition was sold to Daisy and Edgar Tucker.  It is likely the land remained prairie until 1923.  It is believed that the first building on the property was a one room office, which served as a sales point for the Hurst Addition’s platted lots.  The lot may also have served for storage of building materials.  It is the front part of the cottage that still stands today.  A few more rooms were later added, bringing the square footage up to about 800.  One of the bedrooms was built over a large cistern that originally provided water to the building.  

The property exchanged hands several times from 1924 until 1930.  We will jump to the most interesting owners.

                                                                                ***** 

One couple, Elenor and Arthur Hestwood lived in the small home for forty years. Arthur was a professor and choral director at the University of Tulsa. He earned a Master’s Degree at Northwestern in Chicago, and then moved to New York City as a featured tenor soloist with Fred Waring’s Pennsylvanians. He also sang with the Robert Shaw Collegiate Choral and RCA Victor Chorale under maestro Arturo Toscanini. In 1946 he was recruited to join the University of Tulsa music faculty. He directed a weekly music show on the TU radio Station, KWGS. Later, in 1957, he started a semi-professional chorale for the Tulsa community in which people from all walks of life. 

Arthur’s wife, Elenor, was his accompanist and believe it or not, they had a grand piano in the tiny house!  
                                                                                   *****
The property was owned by Major Frank VanVoorhis from 1930 through 1944. He did not live there, but rented the small cottage before transferring the property to his brother in 1944. 

Frank was born on November 12, 1859 in Washington County, Pennsylvania. As a young man he ventured west and spent time in St. Louis, Kansas City, Dodge City and Coffeeville, Kansas before making his way to Indian Territory.

Frank took part in an 1899 buffalo hunt along the Canadian and Red Rivers. To prepare for the journey, he purchased an “Indian Pony” and a pair of moccasins from Cheyenne Indians who he says “had broken loose into Kansas” and whom “government officers were taking back to territory.” Sixty years later he still had the moccasins and bragged they were “as good as the day I bought them.”

Frank described hundreds of buffalo hunters in camps near Fort Elliot in the Texas pan handle on the Red River. One group of hunters bragged they had killed 1800 buffalo and sold their hides for 50 cents each. During his own hunt, Frank and his pony were nearly trampled trying to rope a buffalo. Frank and his party only killed what they could fit in their wagon, selling the hides and brining the meat for preservation. Then, as they forded the swollen South Canadian River on the way back to Dodge City, Kansas, the hunting party nearly lost everything they had worked for. He stated that when they made it home there was “nothing much to show for it, except the adventure.”

Frank continued to make a life in the West, raising cattle and horses.  He even traveled to South America in 1893, hunting longhorn cattle for hides, horns and tallow.  Back in Kansas and Indian Territory, land was an open free range.  In 1900, about 6 miles northwest of Checotah, Oklahoma Frank began ranching and free ranging Aberdeen Angus cattle.   He befriended Chief Pleasant Porter, Chief of the Creek Nation, who also began raising purebred cattle and horses.  When the free-range days came to an end, Frank sold his herd in “old Mexico.” 

After statehood in 1907, Frank invested in real estate in the Tulsa area and joined the Oklahoma National Guard.  He was involved in both the Spanish American War, World War I and the Tulsa Race Massacre.  He was interviewed about the event in 1937 by Effie S. Jackson for the Indian-Pioneer History Project at his home at 823 E. 6th Street

Frank recounts that following the initial call, consultation with his commanding officer and the Oklahoma Governor:

I took an army truck and 20 men and proceeded to the police station on West Second Street.  From there we went to where the Frisco Station used to be at First and Boston.  There was some firing back and forth between Blacks and whites.  We were not to fire until fired upon….at that time there were no buildings on fire.  Realizing that the maddened armed whites were our worst problem, it seemed best to get between the two forces.  So we marched up North Boulder around the back of Stand Pipe Hill and slipped back down to First Street and Archer in that way getting a position between opposing forces. 

Frank goes on to recount that “maddened whites” attempted to besiege the armory to obtain munitions.  He stated, “In some respects the maddened whites were our worst problem.”  After the armory was secured, Frank returned to Greenwood to find Blacks in groups of 20-30.  He stated they were rounded up, disarmed and escorted to the Convention Hall (Brady Theatre today renamed Tulsa Theater).  Frank also stated:

 It was surprising the number of negroes in army attire (World War uniforms) found secreted in houses.  Even wore their war helmets, well supplied with long range Winchesters, often provided with 20-30 round of ammunitions.

Early in the morning of June 1st, Frank sent word for a cease fire and asked for surrender.

“Though the negros were through, gladly surrendering, the whites were in a state of frenzy, killing negros at random; bragging about how many they killed and keeping up the horror by burning and plundering negro homes.  It took the troops to quiet them and drive them out of the burned and pillaged negro district.  How many negroes were killed will never be known.  After all these years I feel that real damage was the fire and not serious loss of life.  As for guards (under his command) one had ear clipped and another a hat shot off his head.  There were only about 35 in action.  State troops were sent in on June 1st but the riot was already quelled and quiet had restored. “

*****


Major Frank VanVoorhis and wife, May 30th, 1943.

Photographs from personal collection of Ken Rose.  Used with permission.

*****

At the time this blog post was written, the city of Tulsa was excavating the site of a possible mass grave from the Race Massacre in Oak Lawn Cemetery. 

Oaklawn Cemetery, July 13th, 2020

*****

References:

Jackson, E.  (1936)  Indian-Pioneer History Project.  Transcribed interview with Maj. Frank VanVoorhis. 

Property Abstract from lots one and two, Hurst’s Re-subdivision of Block 5, Fair Acres Addition, Tulsa, Tulsa County, Oklahoma.

Rose, Ken.  (2020 July)  Personal Communication with permission to use photographs of VanVoorhis.

Wood, Mike.  (2020 July 8, 10 & 13)  Personal Communication.

Other photographs by A. Mueller

Post edited by P. Casey Morgan



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

One Family- One House- One Hundred Years

  Part I:   Rosemont Heights Rosemont Heights was one of the earliest divisions or ‘additions’ of land that was graded, platted with lots for sale in what is now as the Renaissance Neighborhood.   It was platted in 1911.   Originally Muscogee Creek land, it was allotted to Mary Jane Perryman in the early 1900's.   Mary Jane  would have been about 17 years old in 1911.  She  had married young and by 1911 she and her first husband, John Robert Harkness, already had three children.   It would be very interesting to know how much she was paid for the property when purchased by a Mr. John P. Given.  According to her niece, Wavel Ashbaugh, interviewed in 2015 by Voices of Oklahoma, Native people were often taken advantage of with complex land contracts and white settlers"...didn't pay very much for it...".   The present-day boundaries of Rosemont Heights are Delaware Avenue to South Florence Avenue and Thirteenth Street to Fifteenth Street.   Note:   The original plats

O.U.R. Streetcar: The Trolley that Ran Through Renaissance

  1911 Tulsa Postcard Courtesy of Tulsa Historical Society.  Used with Permission. Tulsa’s transportation system has evolved from horse-drawn wagons and buggies to streetcars, jitneys, automobiles, electric bicycles, and scooters. (“Jitney” was slang for a five cent piece.   Small buses that carried people for 5 cents a ride became known as jitneys.) From 1905 through 1935 an electric double rail trolley system wound through the city carrying hundreds of Tulsans to work, shopping, recreation and back home again.   This is a short history of the Tulsa streetcar system, including one line that ran  through present day Renaissance.   Before the introduction of the trolley in 1905, horse-drawn vehicles were the primary mode of transportation. Tulsa's horses were well accustomed to the unpaved, dusty, and sometimes mud-filled roads. Hitching posts in front of homes and businesses were common at the time.   In November 1905, Tulsa Mayor C. L. Reeder signed an ordinance that set fare